I have used Old Fashioned Milk Paint before but I wasn't crazy about the results. With that particular piece, I didn't sand it at all. This resulted in a VERY chippy look, which I didn't like it and long story short….stripped that piece and went a different route.
I decided to sand this buffet. It wasn't super glossy but I was already going against every bone in my body by not removing doors, painting over the hinges and not priming, so I didn't want to push it and give my self a complete anxiety attach by not sanding it also! Plus, even though I know this product has a mind of it's own, I wanted to be able to control the chippiness a little bit.
After sanding, vacuuming and giving it a good wipe down. I mixed my product as instructed on the package and started painting.
I ended up doing 2 coats, 3 in some areas of the color Barn Red.
I wasn't impressed with the flat and dull finish at this point and got a little nervous but knew I would be sealing it, so didn't have a full panic attack.
It did flake and chip off in most of the areas you see. I used a putty knife for that but probably because I sanded it, I needed to distress it a little bit by hand as well.
Not looking pretty at this point whatsoever!
I did 2 coats on the top.
Just for the record...I would never do this (seal by hand) with one of my sprayed pieces but it works beautifully on a hand painted, antiqued piece.
My worries about the flat finish quickly disappeared when I saw how nice it looked with the sealer. I did not want this piece to have a lot of shine, but just a nice luster and blend in the rough looking areas from using the putty knife. It also deepened the tone of the wood peaking through.